“Amityville Horror” killer Ronald DeFeo Jr. – who shot and killed his entire family all whilst they peacefully slept in their beds – has died at age 69.

He died behind bars on March 12th, 2021, while serving a 25-years-to-life sentence at Sullivan Correctional Facility in Fallsburg, New York, according to the state Department of Corrections. An autopsy by the Albany County Medical Examiner’s Office will determine an official cause of death.

On the night of November 13th, 1974, DeFeo Jr. (also known as “Butch”) shot his parents, two brothers and two sisters with a .35 caliber rifle.

moviepilot.com

Above are the DeFeo children (back row, left to right): John (age 9), Allison (age 13), Marc (age 12). (Front row): Dawn (age 18), Ronald “Butch” Jr. Their parents Ronald (age 44) and Louise (age 42) are not pictured.

6. What Happened Before The Murders?

filmdaily.co

At his 1975 trial, DeFeo admitted killing his parents and siblings. His attorney, William Weber, tried the insanity defense; allegedly DeFeo was a young man driven to kill by an abusive father and a build-up of tension in the family home. The jury rejected the insanity plea and DeFeo was handed six life sentences.

However, according to many sources, violence was commonplace at the DeFeo family home. Ronald DeFeo Sr. was a powerfully built man weighing 280 pounds who would regularly beat his wife, Louise DeFeo.

Louise was allegedly very close to her father, Michael Brigante, and the family was financially dependent on his wealth as he paid the mortgage on the house. Ronald Sr. was also employed at Brigante’s car dealership and it’s believed this left him feeling emasculated. He would take out his frustration and rage on his wife when he arrived home.

DeFeo one said, “How the hell can my father be a man when her father’s always there? They were ready to get a divorce.”

Linnea Nonnewitz, Louise’s housekeeper and close friend, confirmed, “(Louise) wanted to die. She wanted to put her head in the oven. She said to me, ‘Linn, I’m preparing you. Something so tragic is going to happen.'”

This version of events does provide a clearer explanation of why DeFeo suddenly decided one night to assassinate his entire family in their sleep. Did he believe that death was a lesser cruel reality than what they were faced with at home?

5. Had DeFeo Killed His Family For $200,000?

allthatsinteresting.com

One of the main frustrations for the prosecution was finding a solid motive behind the murders. An appointed psychiatrist for the prosecution found that DeFeo was an abuser of heroin and LSD, had an antisocial personality disorder, and was aware of his actions at the time of the crime.

It is believed but not confirmed that DeFeo wanted to collect a $200,000 life insurance policy after his family was killed. Most likely to feed his insatiable and spiralling drug habit.

The Suffolk deputy chief medical examiner, Dr. Howard C. Edelman said: “There have been reports that Mr. DeFeo allegedly, shot his family because he would have been the beneficiary of a $200,000 insurance policy – and the police have not ruled this out a possibility in their investigation.”

The Amityville House at 112 Ocean Avenue, which DeFeo would have inherited if proven innocent, was also worth $75,000 house at the time of the murders. In 2010, it was purchased for $950,000.

4. Why Did Nobody Wake Up?

amityvillefiles.com/murders
amityvillefiles.com/murders

All six murdered members of the family were found in their respective beds in separate rooms with their faces down and hands raised above their heads. There was no sign of a struggle. A pathologist told the New York Post, “It is bizarre that they were all in the exact same position.”

Dr. Edelman said that there was “no possibility that a silencer could be put on a rifle with which they were shot.” They were all shot at close range with the barrel of the gun placed close to the bodies. The parents were shot twice each in the back, the boys were shot once each in the back and the two girls were shot once each in the head.

Many speculated that the murders could not have been possible without a silencer on the gun. Neighbors also reported there were no sounds of gunfire – only the family dog, Shaggy, was heard barking wildly throughout the night. How had Butch been able to move from room to room, shooting each victim without stirring the others?

There has been a long-standing theory that in order to carry out the murders with all victims sleeping soundly in their beds that there had to be a second shooter. In 2012, documentary filmmaker Oldham Ryan Katzenbach said, “This crime did not happen the way it is commonly accepted. We firmly believe that there was indeed a second gun involved in the commission of the crime.” If there was a second gun involved in the crime – then who was the accomplice?

3. Did Butch Drug His Family At Dinner?

9news.com.au

DeFeo himself had his own theory for why the family slept through his murder spree – he had drugged them all at dinner. DeFeo reportedly told the police that he administered heavy doses of barbiturates the evening before the murders.

Dr. Edelman reported: “There is a good possibility they were drugged. I don’t know how they could keep quiet at the time of the shootings. If there was something, it was in what they ate. The bodies had no needle puncture wounds.”

Although the report did not find any barbituates in the blood results from any of the slain family members – some sedatives can only remain in the system for up to 4 hours. There was a long delay between the family eating dinner and their execution during the early hours of the morning.

DeFeo then did not report the murders until 6.30 pm when he entered Henry’s Bar in Amityville, Long Island, New York, and shouted: “You got to help me! I think my mother and father are shot!”

2. Should DeFeo’s Claims Be Dismissed Entirely?

amityvillefiles.com/murders

In 1986, more than a decade after the murders, DeFeo gave a very different version of events during his first newspaper interview at the Attica Correctional Facility.

The interview with Newsday lasted 2 hours and his “wife” Geraldine Rullo was also present. She told the reporters, “Ronnie DeFeo is a very sweet, tender, loving, giving young man – he really is. I saw all the big macho image he did was a facade.”

DeFeo said he was tired of hearing names like “Mr. Amityville” and “Mr. Horror”. “This ain’t funny no more. People look in my eyes, that I’m possessed or something. I’m sick of it,” he told reporters.

DeFeo claimed on the night of the murders that his sister Dawn (pictured above) told their father she was planning to move to Florida to be with her boyfriend. This claim was confirmed by Dawn’s former classmate, Beverly Nonnewitz, whose mother cleaned the DeFeo family home. Nonnewitz said Dawn had asked her numerous times to take her to Florida. DeFeo said, “There was no way my father was going to let her go to Florida.”

DeFeo said: “My mother’s out of her mind. She’s running around making statements, `You’re all better off dead.’ “

The new account of the murders he gave to the newspaper then reads:

“DeFeo now claims that his sister, Dawn, 18, shot his father, Ronald Sr. Then, he says, his distraught mother shot Dawn and her three youngest children, Allison, 13, Mark, 11, and John, 9. He claims that his mother finished by shooting herself. DeFeo admits flying into a rage when he came on the scene – firing one rifle bullet into his already-wounded mother.”

Adding, “Two people have been protected for this crime since the day it happened, and I am not one of them,” DeFeo said. “My mother and sister did the killings. My mother shot herself. That is a fact. There’s another gun involved. That is a fact.”

There is no official record of the wedding between DeFeo and his alleged wife, Geraldine. The photocopy of their marriage certificate they produced for the newspaper names a city magistrate who has not performed any marriages after 1964. There is also no record of the birth of their daughter in New Jersey.

Gerard Sullivan, the former assistant district attorney who prosecuted DeFeo, said this new confession is inconsistent with key physical evidence. Sullivan stated, “It’s all preposterous. I think it’s been several years since he had any of that attention. What the hell else does he have to do in prison?”

1. How Involved Were The Mafia In The Murders?

variety.com

DeFeo reported the murders to the police himself and his initial statement was that he returned home on the evening of November 13th where he discovered someone had killed every member of his family. DeFeo said the murders were carried out by mafia hitman, Louis Falini.

He later said Falini held a gun to his head and forced him to watch his family be killed. Falini, however, had an alibi that completely checked out – he was out of state at the time.

DeFeo then changed his story and confessed, “Once I started, I just couldn’t stop. It went so fast.”

DeFeo has since claimed that he confessed to the murders because he feared telling the truth would result in retaliation from the Mafia. DeFeo said because his grandfather treated Louise DeFeo like a goddess he would never have believed she was capable of murder.

His grandfather, Michael Brigante, was well-known for his mob connections, and his father’s uncle, Peter DeFeo, was later identified by police as a captain in the Vito Genovese crime family.

DeFeo feared his wife Geraldine and daughter would have been harmed. He said, “I really believe (they) would have stooped low enough to get my daughter. Now Pete DeFeo is dead, Mike Brigante is dead. I ain’t got nothin’ to worry about no more.”

Michael Brigante died in 1985 but according to New York City police sources, Peter DeFeo was still – at the time the newspaper published the interview – very much alive.

Many people still believe the Mafia theory as all of the family members were killed in ‘execution style’. Yet, this is just another disturbing fact in a horror story that has lasted almost half a century.